Philomath city leaders want a pared-down City Hall remodel that focuses on accessibility and security. They also want it to fit within money the city has already set aside.
Members of the Finance and Administration Committee told City Manager Chris Workman last week that they are uneasy about a major spending project on the building after the city cut its 2026-27 budget and added a $5 monthly police services fee to utility bills.
“Just to be blunt, I feel like we either need to strip it way down or it’s not going to happen,” Mayor Christopher McMorran said at the Nov. 12 meeting. “I think that’s kind of my impression of where the council is at this point.”
Workman said he was waiting on an updated estimate from G. Christianson Construction of Corvallis. He has asked the contractor to price the project in current construction dollars and to cut aesthetic elements so the work focuses on security and compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act.
“It’s been over a year since we even got this bid,” Workman said. “So getting an update, I think, would probably be the first step.”
The contractor’s preliminary estimate, dated March 4, 2025, put the project at $516,951 to $598,575. The City Council debated a $421,973 estimate for the remodel in June while reviewing the city’s 2026-27 capital improvement plan.
Workman asked the committee where it stood. If the new estimate came back $200,000 higher, would the city still want to seek bids, or should the project sit for a year?
McMorran said he would not support moving forward if the price rises at all. He said he would have concerns even at the current level “just given our financial challenges.”
The mayor suggested getting a separate estimate for a much smaller project. It would cover only curb ramps, ADA-accessible doors, windows and security improvements, possibly as the first phase of a larger plan.
“I would like to hear that, because that seems almost like no-brainer stuff — keeping people safe, and accessibility,” said City Councilor Spencer Irwin, the committee chair.
McMorran added that his position isn’t about denying staff a better workplace.
“I just think there are some open-ended questions right now on our finances that I would prefer to have be closed-ended before we do something like that,” he said.
McMorran said he would be comfortable spending some of the city’s savings on ADA and security work, “but anything beyond that, I think, would need to wait.”
City Councilor Teresa Nielson said she wants to see what a scaled-back version would cost “in comparison to what this initial enormous remodel would be.”
Workman cautioned that there may not be much left to cut.
“This is already kind of the stripped-down version,” he said. “There’s no fancy anything in this. This is really, what are the needs at City Hall right now?”
The plans would enclose and shrink the lobby, add service windows and a keypad-controlled door, and build ADA-accessible ramps and walkways. Workman said the extra staff workspace in the plan comes from the security changes, which separate employees from people walking in off the street. Removing the workspace would not save money.
He said the need for space has eased somewhat because the city now uses a contract planner instead of an on-site planner “working out of a closet.”
The biggest potential savings are in the two covered entries, Workman said. But he added that new ADA-compliant exterior doors with a security system should be a permanent fix. That work leads to other changes, including removing an interior door and replacing carpet.
“Everything kind of ties in,” he said.
Workman said the city could skip the new siding. The 2025 estimate lists that item at $79,825 to $92,429 for the building’s west face. In total, he estimated that $100,000 to $200,000 might be cut from the project.
“That puts us back to the money that we’ve got saved up, but we can’t do the ADA and security for a couple hundred thousand,” he said. “It’s still going to be over a $400,000 project.”
Irwin pointed to the budget cuts and rate and fee increases in saying, “We certainly need to be well within what’s already saved and budgeted.”
Asked whether spending up to the full amount saved would be acceptable, Irwin said he’d prefer to come in under it.
“‘Hey, we saved money on this project’ feels a lot different than ‘we spent every penny available,'” he said.
Irwin also said nothing staff has requested is unreasonable. He warned that cutting too much could leave the city with “a really expensive Band-Aid that we’ll just have to deal with later.”
Nielson said the city must find “some sort of happy medium” between a worthwhile long-term remodel and a budget the council is comfortable with.
“It is hard for me to justify an extreme amount of overage when we’ve asked for a lot of things from our community,” Nielson said. “It feels almost a little bit hypocritical, and I’m not comfortable with that piece.”
Workman said the improvements would be permanent because they are at the front of the building. Any future expansion of City Hall would likely go toward the back.
“This is really not an expansion,” he said. “This is a remodel within the existing footprint.”
Workman also said the police services fee doesn’t free up money for other capital projects.
“Money going toward the police department doesn’t necessarily help with money toward City Hall and ADA improvements and other projects,” Workman said. “They’re different projects.”
The council approved the fee in July. The money goes to the police department to help close a gap between city revenues and expenses.
Workman said he will keep working with the contractor to identify cuts that won’t have long-term consequences, and he will bring updated numbers back to the committee.
“I think we’ll have to have numbers, and then it’d be easier to make decisions about what works,” Irwin said. “But I think we’re on the right track.”
Committee meets again Wednesday
The Finance and Administration Committee meets again at 4 p.m. Wednesday at City Hall.The meeting will be livestreamed on the city’s YouTube channel.
The City Hall remodel is not on the agenda. The committee will review social services grant applications and discuss the process for evaluating the city manager. The evaluation process was also a topic at the committee’s Nov. 12 meeting.
